The why and where of Milk Bars in 2015

I was walking down the street a few nights ago when two people zoomed past on bikes. I could hear them talking and one of them exclaimed, “A milk bar! Do they still have those? Who would ever go there?”

I looked over my shoulder at the shop I’d just gone past and sure enough, there was nobody inside.

It got me thinking.

I live in a suburb with three milk bars* within a few minutes walk of my house. (*a milk bar, for those unaware, is like a very small grocery shop selling the bare essentials with a focus on lollies, ice-cream and tinned goods. In parts of the world it may be called a general store, a corner store, a deli or a dairy.) Why is that? In my whole life, I’ve never been so near to so many milk bars.

2 minutes 40 walk to this one: IMAG2941

3 minutes walk to this one:IMAG2943

6 minutes 40 walk to this one:

IMAG2935
Complete with core demographic of kids on holidays.

These are not sophisticated places. They have so little internet presence you can’t even find them on Google Maps. They don’t even have names. They exist principally for locals to pick up a few things.

I remember when I was a boy of about five, the milk bar near my family home closed. At that stage I’d only gone there to get lollies once or twice, but I sure was disappointed. I understood that as the end of an era. Retail was consolidating into a few big supermarkets and people didn’t need milk bars any more.

I subsequently moved to a house in North Fitzroy that had one milk bar nearby but I only used it once, when I was halfway through cooking and realised I needed another tin of tuna. It cost $7. So milk bars stopped figuring in my life. Until I moved to Clifton Hill. Then they were everywhere.

The three milk bars pictured above differ in their product offerings.

The closest one sells newspapers, has a coffee machine, sells Baklava and stocks a moderate range of groceries.

The second closest one does some deep-fried takeaway foods and stocks a minimal range of groceries.

The furthest one has DVDs, does dry-cleaning and stocks a minimal range of groceries.

There’s also, in this suburb, a continental supermarket, which I almost consider a milk bar. But since it calls itself a supermarket I will give it the benefit of the doubt. It is all of 40 metres away from one of the milk bars.

I was trying to explain to myself what it might be about the nature of this particular quiet, leafy, left-wing pocket of the inner north that made it so inclined to milk bars. Might the residents tend to be very forgetful and need to pop out for more cat food? Might they prefer not driving to the shops? Might they be opposed to big supermarkets? Any of these seemed unlikely given the rest of the inner north is demographically similar.

The reason, I eventually concluded, is the absence of big supermarkets. Clifton Hill is tucked into a bend of Merri Creek and that makes it probably uneconomical to put a big supermarket here. The above-mentioned Continental Supermarket does an okay job, and there’s a small FoodWorks around 15 minutes walk away too, (although it has earned the nickname ExpensiveWorks.)

I mapped the supermarkets of the region and I can report that it is 2.3 km to the nearest major supermarket, Smith St Woolworths, 2.4 km to Piedimontes supermarket and 3.3 km to Northcote plaza. That is apparently the magic distance you need for milk bars to start clustering.

In the following map, Supermarkets are black dots and the local milk bars are blue dots. I’ve put rings around them to indicate their catchments, for purely illustrative purposes. There are smaller, lighter red rings around the two small “supermarkets” that serve Clifton Hill.  What is most notable is Clifton Hill is rare in being so far from a major supermarket.

Supermarkets of the inner north
Click to open larger

In a lot of the inner north, the red circles overlap. This suggests higher population density, sterner competition, and perhaps lower willingness of residents to drive to the supermarket. I suspect in much of Melbourne, the red circles would be far apart, leaving gaps just like Clifton Hill, but the population density would not be enough to support such a density of milk bars.

I’d be very interested to hear about other regions that seem to support disproportionate numbers of milk bars. Do they also fall into the cracks, more than 2.4km from a major supermarket? Or are there other reasons you can think of for their continued existence?

Published by

thomasthethinkengine

Thomas the Think Engine is the blog of a trained economist. It comes to you from Melbourne Australia.

5 thoughts on “The why and where of Milk Bars in 2015”

  1. I find it interesting that these contemporary ‘milk bars’ are more general stores aka the ‘local corner store’. In my childhood/ youth growing up in country NSW, milk bars were the precursor of the café – a popular place to have the traditional milkshake, cuppa and a snack right up to a mixed grill. Very popular with families, women having a social catchup for morning/afternoon tea and teenagers after school. Some had a juke-box for that clientele. They ranged from basic laminex top tables and metal chairs to wood-panelled premises with mirrors behind the ‘bars’ and banquette seating and were often called the “Paragon Milk Bar”.

    Like

  2. Are there many schools close by ensuring children pass by regularly? Alternatively, is there simply a high density of foot traffic in general in the location? For example, if someone is walking the dog past the store, and thinks to themselves that they need milk for breakfast, they are more likely to pop in and buy a litre, rather than go home, get out the car, and drive to the supermarket to do so.

    Other demographics to consider might include age of population, socio-economic status, and car ownership. If you were inclined, you could also contact the Victorian Department of Health, to see if any of their dietitians/nutritionists have conducted any research in the local area. They often map “food deserts”, where there are minimal supermarkets/greengrocers/butchers.

    Like

  3. I remember going to milk bars and corner stores a lot in my childhood and they usually served food. I think they are only viable where pedestrian traffic is sufficient – older suburbs, near public transport or in the inner city. In high density cities where people live without cars corner stores seem to be still popular.

    Like

  4. I feel your post ask for a close investigation and some well conducted interviews of the milk bars owners.
    After now five years in Melbourne I have never crossed a milk bar door. All I can say is: they are in direct competition with servos and 7-11. This plus all you wrote raise the question: do they really care about making money?

    Like

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s