Economics is not about “money”

Like most people who care about economics, read about it or talk about it, from time to time people say this to me:
“I couldn’t get interested in economics. I just don’t care enough about money.”
They say it dismissively. As though economics was about money.
Economics is about people.
Take the latest work by one of my favourite economists, Professor Jeff Borland. He produces a “labour market snapshot” each month that he emails to interested parties. The April one was focused on the plight of the young.
“Employment prospect of the young in Australia have weakened considerably since the GFC,” he writes.
The biggest fall in employment is among those who are not in full-time study.
This is not an academic issue. It’s a goddamn human tragedy. Unemployment at this tender age correlates with worse outcomes on just about every measure.
“Unemployment while young can lead to long-term reductions in wages, increased chances of subsequent periods of unemployment and poorer health outcomes,” according to UK economists.
Brotherhood of Saint Laurence executive director Tony Nicholson: “And in our modern economy that means that they’re really being sentenced to a lifetime of poverty.”
“One in three (32 per cent) long-term unemployed youngsters have contemplated suicide and one in four (24 per cent) in this group admitted to self-harming,” according to a UK survey reported in early 2014.
This blog from the Peterson Institute for International Economics: “Considerable research suggests that less stable employment experiences of young people can lead to “scarring” that affects their future employment and earning prospects.”
The critics of economics implicitly accuse it of reification – that by creating ways of quantifying and measuring the material world they bring materialism to the centre.
There could be a germ of truth there. But to not study the material world in a systematic way would be to deny the real influence it has on humans’ experience of their lives.

Published by


Thomas the Think Engine is the blog of a trained economist. It comes to you from Melbourne Australia.

5 thoughts on “Economics is not about “money””

  1. “There could be a germ of truth there. But to not study the material world in a systematic way would be to deny the real influence it has on humans’ experience of their lives.”

    Thumbs up. When the economy goes bad, people suffer. But there are no short-cuts.


  2. Tom, from a communist perspective, I have to congratulate you on your insight: Karl Marx goes to great length to explain how in capitalism, production relationships are really only the expression of social relationships mis-represented as economic relationships. Marx’s whole criticism of capitalism as ‘Commodity Fetishism’, as the superstitious worship of money, pretty much develops from there.


  3. People make choices in their lives. Many of these are financial or material.
    People choose to buy things, or not. Business people make decisions to invest, or not.

    All these individual decisions have collective consequences that are measurable. That’s what economics does. It measures the consequences of peoples’ choices.

    Decision-making is psychological – and I’d argue, primarily emotional – based on current confidence and future expectation.

    So, economics is the mathematical expression of mass or social psychology.


  4. Is it not the understanding of economics which is at fault in such a comment, but the understanding of what money is, and more to the point, what is the cause or basis behind both money and why people wish to engage in ecomomic activities to begin with? Can either exist in isolation?


    1. True, people isoloate money from value: money is the way we communicte value and it helps us allocate effort to what other’s value, if we want them to value it in return. It helps us avoid a long discussion with the butcher on what one’s value is….one merely hands over the money he wants to represent your value of his effort.

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Comment

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s